News

[Podcast] Reputation Matters: Episode 23 | Michele McConnell

October 14, 2026

Michele McConnell: Behind the Curtain of The Phantom of the Opera

Michele McConnell took the Broadway stage by storm when she was introduced into her new role as Carlotta in the world-renowed musical, The Phantom of the Opera. After 2,228 performances and ultimately breaking the record as the longest-running Carlotta in the show’s history, Michele opens up about her journey to the top and the relationships she built along the way. She gives us an inside look at what it really takes to sustain excellence in the spotlight, and is a reminder that careers are rarely built overnight.

What does it take to build a lasting career on Broadway, earn the trust of your peers and maintain a reputation that stands the test of time?

In this episode of @Reputation Matters, Michele McConnell, Broadway performer, soprano and educator, shares the story behind her remarkable career in musical theater, including her record-setting run as Carlotta in The Phantom of the Opera. After spending more than a decade building her career in New York, McConnell joined the Broadway production in 2010 and went on to become the longest-running actress to portray Carlotta in Broadway history.

The conversation explores the perseverance, discipline and professional relationships that helped shape McConnell’s career. She reflects on the years of work that preceded her Broadway breakthrough, the challenges of navigating a competitive entertainment industry and the importance of continuing to show up, even when success takes longer than expected. Her experience offers a closer look at what it takes to turn talent and determination into a sustainable career.

McConnell also discusses what it means to perform the same role thousands of times while maintaining consistency and excellence. Having portrayed Carlotta more than 2,200 times, she offers insights into the preparation, commitment and mindset required to deliver night after night. Her experience highlights an important lesson about reputation: long-term success is built not only on talent, but also on reliability, professionalism and the trust you establish with the people around you.

Beyond Broadway, the episode examines how reputation carries across different professional environments. Through her work as an educator and her involvement in business, McConnell has experienced the importance of connecting with people, communicating effectively and representing herself with confidence and authenticity.

For aspiring performers, business professionals, leaders and anyone working to build a lasting career, this episode offers a thoughtful look at perseverance, professional reputation and the value of consistency. McConnell’s journey demonstrates how the principles that sustain a Broadway career can extend far beyond the stage.

Why listen?

In this episode of Reputation Matters, Michele McConnell shares lessons from her record-setting Broadway career and her journey to becoming one of the most enduring performers to portray Carlotta in The Phantom of the Opera. The conversation explores how perseverance, relationships, professionalism and trust contribute to lasting success; and why the reputation you build along the way can be just as important as the opportunities you pursue.